imagemap
Antonio VIVALDI (1658-1741)

Concertos Nos. 1~4 from
Il Cimento dell'Armonia e dell'Invenzione, Op.8

(The Contest between Harmony and Invention)

The Four Seasons

Picture by Lois and Bob Schlowsky, ©Tony Stone Images - taken from cover of Telarc CD83417.


An inktroduction by René Chia

Recordings of The Four Seasons literally number in the hundreds. As such, choosing one for investment or for review must necessarily be selective. For this survey of available recordings, upcoming reviews are listed below with those which are available now at the Inkpot.

In reviewing these performances, I will of course consider the quality of recording as well as the skill of the performers. In addition, I will highlight and recommend those which show creativity or inventiveness of interpretation.

Everyone has his or her favourite movements, and mine is the beautiful "Winter Largo". For each season, I will also look out for the sleeping goatherd and barking dog of Spring , the violin solo storm in Summer, and "The Hunt" in Autumn. Pick your favourite Seasonings and bon appétit !

Note: in all reviews, "Spring I" refers to the first movement of Spring; "Autumn II" means the second movement of Autumn, etc. Couplings in the CDs, if available, are listed but not reviewed. The first name in each entry refers to the violin soloist.

Vivaldi's Four Seasons: A Survey of Recordings

Marco Pedrona with the Ensemble Guidantus Reviewed by Chia Han-Leon.

DATUM DAT 80001
full-price. Modern instruments with sound effects.

Takako Nishizaki with the Capella Istropolitana Reviewed by Chia Han-Leon.

NAXOS 8.550056.
Budget-price. Modern instruments.

Andrew Manze with the Amsterdam Baroque Orchestra

ERATO 4509-94811-2.
Full-price. Period performance.

Piero Toso with I Solisti Veneti

ERATO Baroque Collection (Vol.14): 4509-99666-2 .
Mid-price. Modern instruments.

Jeanne Lamon with Tafelmusik

SONY Vivarte SK48251.
Full-price. Period performance.

Mariana Sirbu with I Musici

PHILIPS 446 699-2.
Full-price. Modern instruments, with lute in continuo.

Salvatore Accardo, with I Solisti di Napoli

PHILIPS Solo 442 393-2 (mid price) or 422 065-2 (full price).
Period violin, but modern-style performance.

Christopher Warren-Green, with the London Chamber Orchestra. Reviewed by Chia Han-Leon.

VIRGIN CLASSICS "Duo" VBD5 61466-2.
Superbudget-price (2 CDs for 1 mid-price). Modern instruments. Set contains numerous other Vivaldi concertos.

Amsterdam Guitar Trio

RCA VICTOR Gold Seal 09026-61652-2.
Mid price. Transcription for three guitars.

Gottfried von der Goltz with the Freiburg Baroque Orchestra & the Harp Consort

DEUTSCHE HARMONIA MUNDI 05472-77384-2.
Full-price. Period performance, with additional plucked-string consort.

Franke/Garibova/Laurin (solo violins) with mixed ensemble.

EARTHBEAT! Records 9-42584.
Full-price. Arranged for string orchestra with various traditional instruments of the world and the sounds of nature.

134: 28.12.97; up.28.9.1998

Readers' Comments


From: Johann D'Souza (Merton@mbox3.singnet.com.sg)

Well one of my favourites is Alan Lovedays no nonsense version with the winter ending off in a climactic climax. He adds a certain touch to his violin few could do when he made the recording with Decca. He is able to bring the loneliness of winter back from the dead. This is done equally well with Nigel Kennedy who has all the theatrics thrown in with his foot tapping the ground and sudden crescendo which make you think that there were major changes to the markings on the piece. However he is terribly exciting and brings a new stand to this very baroque piece. Many people have said that this is a piece that could either scare you into not listening to anything classical or you would just want to hear everything else that Vivaldi wrote.

From: JORDAN (laurat@niagara.com)

Antonio Vivaldi made a very large contribution to clasical music and still he is not known as well as J.S Bach. Without Vivaldi Bach wouldn't be such a famous composer. I just don't think its very fair.

From: David Thomson (laurat@niagara.com)

I am a very big fan of Vivaldi and clasical music.Vivaldi was one of the greastest composers of his time. His music has inspired many people such as Bach and he also inspired me to become a violinist. I believe that his music is very exciting.

From: Alayah (alayah@rocketmail.com)

Vivaldi's pieces are completely breathtaking. How one man could compose music such as that is beyond my imagination. I think the best recording I have ever heard of the 4 Seasons is from the CD titled "The Baroque Experience". The Academy of Ancient Music performs it, conducted by Christopher Hogwood. This is a 5 CD set that costs approx. $50.00. It is the best investment I have made in music in a long time!!

From: Pierre Maret (pmaret@ifhpserv.insa-lyon.fr)

Hello, thank you for your web site. Just a little question : Could you please give me the french (or european) address of DECCA. Thank you in advance. [Dear Pierre, Decca can be contacted at 347-353 Chiswick High Road, London W4 4HS. You can also find more information at http://www.decca.com/. Happy Seasons! - Ed.]

From: Meljoie Pepito (Mel741@mailcity.com / Monday, March 22, 1999 at 18:45:51)

Hi.. I Love Vivaldi classical Music

From: Andrew Tereszkowski (meafordmotel@sympatico.ca / Saturday, July 15, 2000 at 10:01:25)

I believe that Vivaldi made a more than significant contribution to classical music, though not as known as great artists such as Mozart Beethoven, Handel, Chopin and so forth I believe his work is just as and even more impressive then the popular names I believe he deserves more recognition.

From: Maureen (mjgaynor@aol.com / Thursday, June 21, 2001 at 01:36:02)

I am studying the Four Seasons, specifically the Summer Section. I wanted to thank you for these wonderful reviews - reading others opinions is fantastic. What form is he using? ABA ? Thanks again!

From: fhgjfgjhfjghjh (cool@hotmail.com / Tuesday, January 15, 2002 at 05:05:22)

hghgjhhjhjghjhjhjhjhh i am cool

From: Manuel (mrieder@interbaun.com / Tuesday, January 15, 2002 at 06:13:23)

Interesting reviews... How about reviews of Fabio Biondi's two recordings with Europa Galante (Opus 111 and Virgin) and Giuliano Carmignola's recordings with Sonatori de la Gioiosa Marca (Divox) and the Venice Baroque Orchestra (Sony Classical). They're the most recent recordings of the Four Seasons, and Biondi's in particular are among the most controversial readings of these masterpieces.

From: Charlotte Veal (charlyangel47@hotmail.com / Saturday, June 8, 2002 at 03:47:28)

hi, was Vivaldi inspired by a picture or story etc ect and if he was, what was he inspired by? thank you from charlotte

From: kaelah (kaelahausga@hotmail.com / Saturday, July 20, 2002 at 13:47:57)

Is there a website where I can look up what the seasons are about obviously they're about each season, but they tell a different stroy for each season. Is there a website that will tell me in detail the story behind the music? thanks!

From: Andy (andy@freeborough.com / Friday, October 11, 2002 at 07:41:52)

Excellent reviews, thank you. I was played The Four Seasons as a child and have only recently remembered how amazing it is (some 20 years later!) Does anyone know of a good place to see a live performance? I'm based in London, but a trip further into mainland Europe wouldn't be out of the question if reqired. :-) - Andy.

From: emma (shakeyfamily@btinternet.co.uk / Thursday, November 28, 2002 at 05:56:01)

hi, could u please give me vivaldis words to poems and the name of the music he wrote thanx x x x

From: emily ( / Thursday, November 28, 2002 at 05:58:09)

hi, could u please give me vivaldis words to poems and the name of the music he wrote thanx x x x

From: CY (cychen@yahoo.com / Sunday, February 23, 2003 at 15:06:05)

Any place I can find information on the musical analysis of the four season by Vivaldi? Thanks!!!

From: costy (costy23tcm@yahoo.ca / Sunday, March 30, 2003 at 04:52:52)

i want download seasons-vivaldi

From: Lucy (rarhead@hotmail.com / Friday, November 7, 2003 at 17:55:55)

Is there anywhere where I can get a full analysis of Winter from The Four Seasons?

From: Amber (Aed@123.net / Thursday, January 22, 2004 at 15:14:14)

I am a SUPER Vivaldi fan.He is almost all i listen to!

From: Amber (Aed123@msn.net / Thursday, January 22, 2004 at 15:15:16)

I am a SUPER Vivaldi fan.He is almost all i listen to!

From: Herman, S.A (selecta@lantic.net / Tuesday, March 8, 2005 at 16:33:13)

Hi, couls someone please give a website from where I could download "Spring" from Vivaldi's 4 Seasons? I need it for a project for my son. Tnx.

From: b (beckyb1992@hotmail.com / Friday, April 22, 2005 at 07:24:33)

hi! me and my friend are doing a project on vivaldi. i guess you could say that he led an interesting life in some ways...but i hate how he had an affair! what kind of a christian is that! God says to keep our bodies clean and to not destroy our temple! um..do you think you could tell me waht ttypes of songs vivaldi wrote(besides classical if any) and if his music is God-glorifying? its for our project..thanx.

From: Madison (Garnet13194@aol.com / Saturday, May 14, 2005 at 05:06:43)

I like your page but you need to have it where we people can listen to the wonderful song THE FOUR SEASONS.

From: Sala (saladdin_m@hotmail.com / Friday, October 28, 2005 at 04:56:12)

thanks for this beautifull article and i want to ask you if you can send me the musical notes of the four season or a site where its written these notes because i want to learn how to play this magnificant piece , thank you .

From: Beth (xbabez@hotmail.co.uk / Tuesday, February 7, 2006 at 00:36:07)

Hi. Cool website. Im studying vivaldis winter. its kinda cool. Could someone please mail me and tell me how I can get a soundtrack off the internet? Thanks

From: YiPeng Li (yip.rochalie@pacific.net.sg / Tuesday, May 30, 2006 at 00:06:36)

I erally consider the DG Archiv recording by Trevor Pinnock to be the definitive recording, fresh, incisive and dramatic. Yet I would also unreservedly recommend the recording by Gil Shaham, also on DG, for anyone who is averse to period instrument performances.

From: kyle (kwnewland21@tntech.edu / Tuesday, October 17, 2006 at 03:26:46)

What type of form(ABA)is Winter in?

From: anastasia (sexykimberly25@yahoo.com / Wednesday, January 16, 2008 at 04:14:55)

wat good

From: Georgia Katsiroumpa (tzinakat@yahoo.gr / Monday, July 14, 2008 at 22:03:03)

Hello, can anyone give me some information about Vivaldi songs? Are there any recordings of them? I think they are not frequently performed..

From: lbimklqe (kvqwsrdg@smtucojk.com / Friday, August 8, 2008 at 13:03:57)

qvkmijux glrshjhw http://mrrxwgwx.com whcvycfb haoftppq [URL=http://vrdhxdqd.com]vanfjzth[/URL]

From: james (james@hotmail.com / Thursday, September 18, 2008 at 21:56:27)

this is utter nonsense

From: bobinog (bobinog@hotmail.com / Thursday, September 18, 2008 at 21:58:11)

i love this even though i havent listened 2 it

From: Peter Nosko (pnosko@gmail.com / Saturday, September 20, 2008 at 08:31:17)

I came across this looking for a source for a treasured Four Seasons recording that has developed a defect in the last song on the CD (bonus material, not part of the Four Seasons, but beautiful nevertheless). I bought the "Jeanne Lamon with Tafelmusik" version based on this page, but am somewhat disappointed. Perhaps I am one of those that prefers the version I heard first. I wish I could find another copy of mine: Leonard Bernstein's The Royal Edition No. 98 of 100 (Sony SMK 47642). It is only ADD, and with headphones, I can hear one musician breathing during one piece and surprisingly this only added to my listening enjoyment. I'd welcome a source if anyone comes across it. Thanks for the great web page.

From: caughted (caughted@hotmail.com / Thursday, October 2, 2008 at 19:43:21)

i have no idea what this is on about cos i dont really like classical music but it sounds ok(ish)

From: bobinog (bobinog@hotmail.com / Thursday, October 2, 2008 at 19:46:00)

I think yhis is great and i love it. no really, i LOVE IT. i want to marry vivaldi but he is dead by the way, bobinog is my real name

 

Explore the Flying Inkpot

They're Alive!
Concert Reviews

Bit deadish:

Other Resources at The Flying Inkpot
Home
Sponsored Ads