Return to Classical Contents Page Find Old Articles Contact Writers Go to Inkpot.com

Issue 104
This article was last updated on
16 March, 2001

More Stuff:


Anna Magdelena Notebook 1725. Behringer (Hänssler).

Art of Fugue, The (arr. Amsterdam Loeki Stardust Quartet). ALSQ (Channel).

English Suites. Levin (Hänssler).

Goldberg Variations - An Inktroduction with links to individual reviews


Harpsichord Music by the Young Bach. Hill (Hänssler).

2- & 3-Part Inventions. Fantasia, BWV906. Chromatic Fantasie and Fugue. Hewitt (Hyperion).

Klavierbüchlein for Wilhelm Friedemann Bach. Payne (Hänssler).

 

Six Partitas (harpsichord). Leonhardt (Veritas).

Six Partitas (harpsichord). Pinnock (Hänssler).

Toccatas BWVs 910-916. Watchorn (Hänssler).

Toccata, BWV 911. Partita No.2, BWV 826. English Suite No.2, BWV 807. Argerich (DG).

Transcriptions for Piano by other Composers. Lauriala (Naxos).

 

Organ Music Vols.89 (The Young Bach - A Virtuoso) and 94 (Hänssler). Zerer/Johanssen (Hänssler). By Margaret Chen.

The Leipzig Chorales BWV 651-667. Bryndorf (Hänssler)

Johann Sebastian BACH (1685-1750)

Edition Bachakadamie Vol.115

Six Partitas (Clavier Übung I), BWV 825-830

CD1 [72'02]
Partita No.1 in B flat major, BWV 825
Partita No.2 in C minor, BWV 826
Partita No.6 in E minor, BWV 830

CD2 [77'02]

Partita No.3 in A minor, BWV 827
Partita No.4 in D, BWV 828
Partita No.5 in G, BWV 829

TREVOR PINNOCK harpsichord
(David Way, Stonington Connecticut 1983, after Hemsch)

HÄNSSLER Classic CD 92.115
2 discs [2h 29:04] mid-price

 
by Benjamin Chee

Bach was a composer for whom the suite, or partita, for a solo instrument, with its dance-like movements, was preferable over other forms. One only has to count the bodies of work of his in this medium: English Suites BWV 806-811, French Suites BWV 812-817 and Partitas BWV 825-830 for the clavier, as well as the Lute Suites BWV 995-997, Violin Sonatas BWV 1001-1003 and Partitas BWV 1004-1006, Cello Suites BWV 1007-1012 and Flute Suite BWV 1013.

It is important to specify, however, that this is the set of six partitas for harpsichord from the Clavier Übung I, because there is additionally a seventh partita "in the French Style" BWV 831 from Clavier Übung II. While one might reasonably have expected it to have been included in this set, such a move would have necessitated the addition of a third disc: the six Partitas, just as they are, fill both discs to seventy-two and seventy-seven minutes respectively.


The Art of Flattery, Op.2

We have mentioned elsewhere about Bach's art of flattery. The first partita was written to commemorate the birth of the first son of his patron and friend Prince Leopold and Princess Charlotte Frederica Wilhelmina, with a dedication that began:

Most excellent, gentle prince,
You may still be in swaddling clothes
But your princely eye looks more than adult,
Pardon, if I should rouse you from your sleep,
By my playing sheet taking its bow before you.
This is the very first fruit offered by my strings;
You are the first prince to be kissed by your princess,
And she should be the first to sing your praises,
Because you, like this sheet, are a firstling for the world...

This ode continues by deriving the most beautiful harmonies from the child's screaming and offers eternal delight - subject to the condition that Bach should continue to be seen as "the most profound servant" (that is, that he could keep his job of musical director at Cöthen).

But things, as history proves, didn't work out. Prince Leopold died when the child was three, for which Bach wrote a huge funeral paean, Lament, children, lament the world BWV 244a, incorporating music from the St Matthew Passion. Today, the text remains but the music is lost. Thus did Bach's relations with Cöthen end - Bach eventually lost his job, moving on to the Court of Saxony-Weißenfels under Duke Christian.

The six clavier Partitas date from Bach's time in Leipzig, circa 1726 - 1730. These had already been written and published separately before appearing under the Clavier Übung I of 1731. On the other hand, when the first Partita appeared in 1726, Bach did explicity call it Partita I, implying that he had every intention of writing additional Partitas. The sixth and last Partita did not appear until 1730, by which time Bach was preparing to publish the first Clavier Übung.

The collection, which appeared in 1731, also marked a first for Bach: the first time he gave a major work an opus number. Thus did these works appear as Clavierübung opus 1, "consisting of preludes, allemandes, courtantes, sarabandes, gigues, menuets, and other gallantries." In no uncertain terms, he goes on to state that the music was "composed for lovers of this music for their enjoyment." Collectively, Bach had already stopped referring to these works individually as "Partitas", as they were when they were written and published piecemeal.

 

Conductor-harpsichordist Trevor Pinnock returns to record this work again more than ten years after his first effort on the Partitas (on the DG Archive label, 415 493-2). Interestingly, he performs this work on a copy of a Hemsch by David Way, as he did in the earlier recording, tuned to uneven temperment (which gives it a timbre well-suited to this reading).

As might be expected, Pinnock plays with a great command of this idiom, with phrasing that allows the music to breathe naturally coupled with an intelligent sense of give-and-take in rubato. There is so much on offer here: the fantastic roulades in the last movement of the First Partita, the subtle deftness in the scherzo of the Third Partita, the noble panache in the courante of the Sixth Partita, and the swinging passpied in the Fifth.

His use of improvised ornamentation is intelligent, without being overly indulgent: for example, the muted plectrum that evokes the dance-like character of the gavotte in the Sixth Partita. The allemande of the Fourth Partita is especially memorable, with its beautifully-rendered melody and infused with romantic warmth.

There is also a poise of rustic flavour in the sinfonia of the Second Partita - which is also the least eloquent among the six. There are, in addition, rare occasions when Pinnock (left) tends to inflate the reading, such as the sarabandes of the First and Fourth Partitas, which are taken a shade too self-consciously, even bordering on the wayward.

Nonetheless, the overall sense of artistry and personality that Pinnock injects into the performance makes this an amazing journey into the music of the great master. The palette of sound which he has at his command is extraordinary, aided in no small part by the raw timbre of the period instrument.

The quality of the recording is crisp, but not airless - Pinnock is not playing in a vacuum. There is an immediacy to the harpsichord's presence which is both transparent and full-bodied. There are some awkward translations in the multilingual sleeve notes, but undoubtedly this is a minor issue. On the whole, this album is yet another successful addition to the discography of the Hänssler Bachakademie.

 

BENJAMIN CHEE is also a doyen of the keyboard, hitting speeds of up to 70 wpm. .

If you wish to Add a Comment to this article, please email your comments to classical@inkpot.com.

Return to Index Return to the Classical Index!...
or Visit the Inkvault archives!
777: 1.7.2000 © Benjamin Chee

All original texts are copyrighted. Please seek permission from the Classical Editor
if you wish to reproduce/quote Inkpot material.