current issue   writers' profiles    concert reviews   the inkvault 



Renee Fleming, soprano
Orchestra Age of Enlightment
Harry Bicket, conductor


DECCA 475 547-2 1 DH
full price


 


Georg Frideric Handel

Semele
: O, Sleep Why Dost Thou Leave Me?
Semele: Endless Pleasure
Scipione: Scoglio d'immota fronte
Orlando: Quando spieghi
Serse: Ombra mai fù
Samson: To Fleeting Pleasures Make Your Court
Rinaldo: Lascia ch'io pianga
Rinaldo: Dunque, I laci d'un volto, Ah! Crudel
Samson: Let The Bright Seraphim
Giulio Cesare: V'adore pupile
Giulio Cesare: Da tempeste il legno infranto
Rodelinda: Ritorno, caro e dolce mio tesoro
Lotario: Sommo rettor del cielo, d'una torbida sorgente
Agrippina: Pensieri
Agrippina: Bel piacere
Alexander Balus: Calm Thou...Convey Me

 


 

Please help this site by visiting our sponsors!
 

by Steven Ang

 
 


In yet another well-timed marketing plan, the popular soprano and her label Decca have clearly aimed this CD release to coincide with her debut in Handel's Rodelinda at the Metropolitan Opera. Harry Bicket, conducting this CD recital with his own Orchestra Age of Enlightenment, will also be handling the Met orchestra during the run of performances. The production will also feature Americans David Daniels, Stephanie Blythe, and the countertenor Bejun Mehta.

And somewhere high up in the gallery, I will be among the thousand-strong crowd yelling "RENEE! RENEE!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Yes, I admit, I am a big, big fan, although it was only a few years ago that  I called her 'Renee Phlegming'. But I've seen the error of my ways, renounced my sinful past, and looking forward to my first pilgrimage to the Mecca of opera, to witness the Goddess (English for Diva) herself in action!

But this article is not about my holiday plans. This article is an impartial, rational critique of the newly released CD (which I bought from Sing Music, 2nd floor of Lucky Plaza). So in my own impartial, rational way, let me just say that this CD RAWKS!!!!!!!!!

Seriously now. Since the baroque revival started, Handel's vocal works have been steadily increasing in popularity, so much so that many of his operas are taking over stage time from the Verdis and Puccinis. Giulio Cesare is certainly the most popular, and gaining momentum in audience numbers in productions world-wide are Semele, Theodora, Serses, and of course, Rodelinda. There are also many notable CDs of Handel's works, notably Bryn Terfel's award winning recital on DG, whom many of my friends have enjoyed. This new release should entice the same group of followers, with its mix of popular arias and rarities, as Renee explains in the CD sleeve, "hence the inclusion of, for instance, "Sommo rettor del cielo, d'una torbida sorgente" from Lotario which has rarely been recorded and the jewel "Calm thou" from Alexander Balus"

And after acquiring numerous victories in the many fields of opera and classical vocal music, as varied as American contemporary operas to bel canto to semi-dramatic parts like the Verdi Requiem (lets not talk about her musical-theatre and 'jazz' efforts), the operatic queen of reinvention is now set on re-fashioning herself as an early music specialist. And she pulls off this new image wonderfully well.

Performance wise, her performance here rates as one of the best in the Handel discography. Unlike the tiny, twittering sopranos usually associated with this repertoire, here's a soprano with a full, velvety tone, like a cool strawberry milkshake. Lyrical in nature but capable enough to tackle the heavy demands of the Verdi Requeim, sung with the experience of a veteran singing-actress, and the virtuosity of a bel canto soprano. In short, Renee can tweeter, trill, and sing runs with the best of them, and she can do it in a style that is all her own.

Detractors of the soprano will have less cause for complaints; if you have heard her American Arias CD and found her English pronunciation indecipherable (as I have), her pronunciation of the English numbers here is much clearer. Gone too, are the excessive scoops and exaggerated sighs. Instead, what we have here is a performance that is as authentic as the baroque experts can get. In the da capo sections, Renee ornaments liberally but not excessively, showing off as much for musical and dramatic reasons, not just for plain vanity.

There are many highlights here. Voice students will immediately go for their homework-exercises, like Rinaldo's Lascia ch'io pianga, and the ever-popular Ombra Mai Fu. Opera lovers will love the Giulio Cesare excerpts and pray for the day when La Renee will take on the role of Cleopatra. Samson's Let the Bright Seraphim, aka Princess Diana and Price Charle's Wedding Theme as sung by Kiri te Kanawa , is done wonderfully well and does not lose out to the latter's famous hit. Handel connoisseurs, such as myself, will also appreciate the excerpts from the aforementioned rarities, as well as the two arias from Agrippina, Pensieri, and Bel piacere (the latter was also reused for Rinaldo.)  

Fans of the Diva too, will love the variety of emotions portrayed. From the vanity of Semele, to Rodelinda's yearning, to Rinaldo's villainess Arimida in her cruel sorrow. Admirers of her dramatic poweress will not be disappointed. The opera queen will also like the popular Serse excerpt, her only male portrayal here. I'm sure Renee in drag will make a really handsome man! My only grouse is that there are no excerpts from Messiah, Handel's most popular work. Also, only one aria from Rodelinda made it to the recording. I would have liked a better preview of what's to come.

The OAE, under Harry Bicket, supported the singer in the warmest, most loving way possible. Having played many of the arias hundreds of times, their knowledge of the music shows, and their partnership with the soloist was a close, intimate collaboration. Renee writes in the CD sleeve, “...the evocative playing of the Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment with Harry Bicket was a constant inspiration. In the heat of recording, I may have actually been heard to swear off ever singing with a modern orchestra again!"

Overall, this is one of the most enjoyable CDs I have bought in a long time. The beautiful cover shot in maroon-red is a big bonus. And in yet another example of perfectly timed marketing, the back cover of the CD sleeve also contains an ad for her new book, called The Inner Voice, The Making of a Singer. Go grab a copy (of the CD) at Sing Music, Lucky Plaza. I award this album 4.5 out of 5 stars.


return to top

Also read: Steven's Journey to the Met

Readers' Comments

From: Brian Clark (bc16661@hotmail.com / Friday, November 5, 2004 at 17:11:42)

While I agree with much of this review, there are several factual inaccuracies that need to qualify the comments made. First and foremost, The Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment is that very rare creature, the director-less orchestra: it belongs solely to the players, and conductors (like Harry Bicket) are *invited* to direct projects. Secondly, Ms. Fleming - diva as she may be (and is that strictly speaking goddess in English; I doubt so), she is not the first hot-blooded opera singer to rid the world of the "twittering sopranos" normally associated with this repertoire - Joan Sutherland, I assume, counts as a diva of her day, and she made several recordings with period instrument bands. Is Anne-Sophie von Otter a twittering voice? Or Bernarda Fink? Cecilia Bartoli? Need I go on? That old prejudice just will not do. What your reviewer must note (and note well) is what this recording owes to the past 30 years of experience of historically aware performance practice (complete with twittering sopranos, I'm afraid, as the "diva" who can get her full-blown voice around some of Handel's coloratura simply does not exist yet); otherwise, why would Ms Fleming be able to "improvise" (if she did!) ornamentation in Da Capo repeats? (And that's just one aspect.) I'm glad a singer of the international standing and radiantly beautiful voice has tapped the unfamiliar as well as the better known works of Handel - I've no doubt (writing as someone who edits music on a regular basis for the OAE) that there was a lot of consultation went on (since there is a similar CD of love duets on the way with Carolyn Sampson and Robin Blaze - though they may twitter too much for your reviewer's liking), and that as intelligent and as widely-read as I know Ms. Fleming to be, I sincerely doubt she'd ever heard of Alexander Balus, let alone sung it. I hope the disc is a great success, and also that your reviewer will reconsider the "twittering sopranos" line... Brian Clark


From: Steven Ang (emanual@excite.com / Sunday, November 7, 2004 at 02:38:20)

This post is in response to Mr Brian Clark's comment on my article. First and foremost, thank you for reading The Flying Inkpot and my work. It is especially gratifying for amatuers like myself to know that our work is appreciated by industry players like you. Based on your comments, I have done some reading about the OAE, and yes, they are a self-led orchestra. I was under the impression that they were founded by Harry Bicket in much the same way that William Christie created Les Arts Florrisant, and Emmanuelle Haïm for Le Concert d'Astrée. It was a factual lapse on my part. Thank you for pointing this out. More importantly, the 'twittering sopranos' remark was supposed to be tongue-in-cheek. In conceiving this piece, my writing style is meant to be light and funny whenever possible, and I think I had set the tone pretty well from the start. The remark is pretty much in the same vein as Wagnerian singers being described as 'foghorns' or 'pig-hollering'. Perhaps I could have placed the joke across in a better way, but I absolutely mean no offense. I own and have enjoyed numorous recordings by Anne-Sophie von Otter, Bernarda Fink, and especially Cecilia Bartoli. I also listen to and learn from such baroque specialists like Andrea Scholl, David Daniels, and Emma Kirkby (my favourite 'twittering soprano') among others. I have also highlighted the American Sophie Daneman, in my opinion one of the best 'twittering sopranos' today, in an earlier article entitled New Singers On The Scene. I am sure Ms Fleming consulted lots of people in preparing for this CD, as is the responsibility of every performer. However, in the interest of brevity, I do not feel the need to include every detail that I imagine could have happened. I also do not need to point out that no music from other Handel rarities such as Rodrigo, Esther, Athalia, Nabal etc were included in the recording. Lastly, the Webster's new World Italian English Dictionary translates the word 'diva' to primarily mean 'goddess'. Opera singers were frequently described as Divas, hence creating its associate meaning of 'superstar'. Once again, thank you for reading my work, and for your kind participation. I appreciate your feedback (and that goes to all the other readers as well!), and wish you all the best! Steven Ang


From: Alan Chan (alanchanishere@yahoo.com / Monday, November 8, 2004 at 16:59:05)

Bravo Steven!


 
Our Awards Write for us! Writers' Profiles Martha Argerich Random Review
All original texts are copyrighted. Please seek permission from the Classical Editor
if you wish to reproduce/quote Inkpot material.







 
 

More Inkpot!

 

 

Inktroductions!

 

  Buying CDs
 


In Singapore, classical music CDs may be bought most inexpensively from SING MUSIC, The number to call is (+65) 6235 8960. The address is 304 Orchard Road #02-75 Lucky Plaza Singapore 238863. Simply mention the magic words "The Flying Inkpot" and receive 10% off all purchases (except for nett items). Make a trip down, you won't regret it!

Some great online sites are :

ArchiveMusic.com :
www.archivmusic.com

Berkshire Record Outlet :
www.broinc.com

Amazon.com:
www.amazon.com www.amazon.ca

MDT : http://www.mdt.co.uk


Crotchet Web Store (UK) www.crotchet.co.uk
Zweitausendeins:
www.zweitausendeins.de


Happy buying! The Flying Inkpot has NO affiliations with any music labels or music stores.

 


  Links to check out
 


Unnatural Acts of Opera - by La Cieca - Don't be put off by the strange name - this self-acclaimed queer operazine, presented by the deliciously camp (but knowledgeable) La Cieca, comes up regularly with historical performances which you can (with the aid of Apple's iTunes music player) download and listen to (you have to subscribe to Unnatural Acts, but it's free). Alternatively you can listen live on the website. Among recent podcasts are a live 1969 La Boheme with Pavarotti and Freni, a live Martha Modl/Ramon Vinay Tristan and much more. "La Cieca" provides her spicy commentary with every episode.