Return to Classical Contents Page Find Old Articles Contact Writers Go to Inkpot.com

 
the flying
inkpot
classical reviews

Richard STRAUSS
(1864-1949)

Ein Heldenleben

Suite from "Die Frau ohne Schatten"
(arr. Erich Leinsdorf)
 

Minnesota Orchestra
Eiji Oue, conductor

REFERENCE RECORDINGS RR-83 HDCD
Total Time [52:08] Full-price

by Derek Lim


The relationship between Eiji Oue and the Minnesota Orchestra lasted all of seven years (1995-2002), during which many discs were made with the audiophile label Reference Recordings, several of which were nominated for Grammy Awards. This is one of them, and as far as this repertoire goes, it's a winner.

THE MINNESOTA ORCHESTRA

The Minnesota Orchestra was founded in 1903 and has had a rich and varied roster of musical directors, including the great Dmitri Mitropoulos, Stanislaw Skrowaczewski and Eugene Ormandy, just to name a few.

First a few words about the recording itself, for this is one of the most splendidly recorded discs I have ever heard. I've heard many good recordings, but this one really takes the cake. The repertoire naturally lends itself to such display but the recording engineer captures the orchestra's colours so richly and vividly that I cannot imagine it bettered.

Great recording quality does not a great performance make, however, and the Minnesota Orchestra play magnificently under Eiji Oue, idiomatically and without a weak link in any section at all. Jorja Fleezanis plays the solo violin part in The Hero's Companion with graceful ease and the music never sags or feels overwrought the way it can sometimes. Oue is a master of orchestral colour and put to rest any lingering doubts I have about this work. For the record, I find Don Quixote more interesting musically and less bombastic, and as a tone poem more successful than Heldenleben. Strauss' self-quotations in The Hero's Works of Peace are nicely brought out and sound good enough that I wanted to hear more of Eiji in this repertoire! The Minnesota Orchestra need make no apologies for their playing; it matches up with the very best.

The Suite from Die Frau ohne Schatten, arranged by Erich Leinsdorf, is not commonly encountered in the concert hall - usually one finds Der Rosenkavalier Suite instead, in its different arrangements. Die Frau ohne Schatten is a problematic opera because of its subject matter and its convoluted plot, but the music itself is the thing and there's enough music in this to have Erich Leinsdorf decide to make a suite out of it stiched together from the orchestral interludes that pepper the opera.

Listeners who enjoy the opera will find much to like here as well, much of it is typical Strauss, sometimes in his dissonant idiom but always with that underlying current of lyricism - it's not the candied stuff of Der Rosenkavalier, but then again anyone who thinks that Strauss starts with Also Sprach Zarathustra and ends with Rosenkavalier definitely needs some horizon broadening - and this suite will do just that. The music is alternately soaring and beautiful and dark and evocative, always with Strauss' inimitable mastery of orchestration that Mahler so admired. Again the orchestra and Oue do themselves proud.

Eiji Oue is now the musical director of the Osaka Philharmonic and the Minnesotta is now with Osmo Vanska. Let us hope that they continue in their separate paths to make music as vibrantly as they do here!
 

Purchases made from the WAMSO Web site through Amazon.com earn money for music education and the Minnesota Orchestra.

Readers' Comments


From: Boris Goodenoff (borisgoodenoff@yahoo.com / Saturday, October 16, 2004 at 02:59:16)

It's a shame that these works must be brought out again, and for full-price consideration. No doubt, a CD only friends and relatives of the artists would be happy with.

Return to Index Return to the Classical Index!...
or Visit the Inkvault archives!

All original texts are copyrighted. Please seek permission from the Classical Editor
if you wish to reproduce/quote Inkpot material.

Issue 118

This article was last updated on
5 October, 2004