Return to Classical Contents Page Find Old Articles Contact Writers Go to Inkpot.com

This article was last updated on
26 June, 2001

Arts Fest Reviews at TFI:

[an error occurred while processing this directive]


Do you have a website relating to classical music performance in Singapore? Tell us about it! Email classical@inkpot.com

Singapore Arts Festival 2001
17 June 2001, Sunday
Victoria Concert Hall

ZURICH SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA

Programme:

Arthur HONNEGER (1892-1955)
Pastorale d'été

HO Chee Kong (b."1960s")
Sapphire Dream WORLD PREMIERE

Max BRUCH (1838-1920)
Violin Concerto No.1 in G minor, op.26

Franz SCHUBERT (1797-1828)
Symphony No.9 in C major, D.944 "The Great"

Performers: Nina KARMON violin
Daniel SCHWEIZER
conductor
NOISE RATING INDEX: 0 (A quiet and appreciative audience. And patient for the Schubert to boot.)
The Noise Rating Index is a partially-objective measurement of pager and handphone blasts, 9pm and 10pm watch beeps, coughing-during-the-pianissimo-bits, intra-audience conversation and other mind-bogglingly inept noises emitted in the concert hall during actual performance of music. It is measured on a scale of 0 to 5, in increasing annoyance.
This review has was not kindly sponsored by anybody.
 
   
by Chia Han-Leon
 

Here's something a little bit unusual - a European orchestra younger than our own Singapore Symphony. The Zurich Symphony Orchestra was founded in 1981 by none other than tonight's conductor, Daniel Schweizer. Though it is relatively young, its expertise and unity is available aplenty, as seen in this concert.

To begin with, this is an orchestra which has honed its ability for uniformity of ensemble and especially tone to consummate levels. The eloquent reading of Honegger's serene Pastorale d'été immediately displayed the ZSO's highly unified sound and seamless intra-orchestral articulation. Its overall tone reminds me of warm silk, a velvety texture with lovely string sheen and melting winds, which Schweizer gradually drew gorgeous pianissimi and even build-ups, all exquisitely sustained throughout the tone poem.

Tonight's concert also showcased Sapphire Dream by Singapore composer Ho Chee Kong, who has the rare honour of being (more or less) the only full-time music lecturer at the National University of Singapore. (And as fate would have it, he came just after I graduated. Dang.) Ho is currently teaching under the University Scholars Programme, of which the reader can find out more here.

The music begins with a rhythmically energetic introduction, with simple but weighty themes over booming basses. The succinct treatment of material, coupled with neat and unpretentious orchestration, gave the work a kind of lightweight contemporary feel - it is neither overtly "modern" nor obviously derivative - in a word, it is a "fresh" composition. Ho ascribes the title Sapphire Dream to the Persian idea that "the colour of the sky was a reflection of a giant sapphire on which the earth rested upon. As the day progressed the gemstone changed its colour" - through the "bright blue of the day, dark midnight blue of the night, and the brilliant colours of sunrise and sunset".

The work displays Ho's compact orchestration, in which massed orchestral sections remain in unified voice (again, well-executed in the hands of the ZSO), while solos capture the listener with their evocative simplicity. The writing is confident, striking a fine balance between lyric melody and intellectual form - indeed, there is an impression of vibrancy (sunrise?), brilliance (day), tranquility and intimacy (midnight?) and for sparkle. The sudden and crisp conclusion on a single streaking chord was a delight.

Nina KarmonGerman-Finnish violinst Nina Karmon (right; photo from her website) gave a poised and unfaltering performance of the Bruch Violin Concerto. With rich and beautifully woody tone, she played with even tone and effortless intonation, in an interpretation which is more aristocratic rather than dramatic. The opening introduction of the work was not as dramatically emotional as I would like, but the consistency of the overall reading was truly impressive. In the background, the ZSO and conductor was superbly, perfectly placed - they emerged in full tutti voice only where appropriate, forming distinct, powerful bridges in the music, emphasizing the unity of the performance.

The rich and yearning lyricism of the slow movement was mesmerising in its lightness of intensity, positioned wonderfully next to the powerfully sculpted climaxes. From this to the finale, the transformation of orchestral tone and musical atmosphere was magnificently flourished. In this brilliant and joyous performance, it was obvious that the soloist led the music, not the conductor or the orchestra - this alone is a rare mark of great concerto performance.

Franz SchubertThe thing about performing Schubert's "Great" Symphony is in keeping the "heavenly length" heavenly. To this end, at first, I thought the ZSO's soft-grained, soft-accented approach might not work, but it does. The playing style of the orchestra was smooth, with soft curves, avoiding hardness on melodic corners. It seemed to me that conductor and orchestra focusses on control of volume - not loud/soft volume, but the units of massed sounds - rather than phrasing (though that is also accomplished skilfully). The result is that, despite a lack of "angularity", there is a palpable sense of order in the performance and the musicians, and the conductor, whose flawless switches between tempi were admirable. Interestingly, these characteristics fit well to the Schubertian model of Classical Romanticism. The aesthetic form is always in sight, while the Romantic fervour comes across in large blocks of majestic music - the latter comes off really well, as in the massive conclusion of the first movement.

Whereas we tend to think that once we can phrase well, we can up the volume - the ZSO's way with the Schubert seems to suggest that the assurance of volume/mass in orchestral sound is the foundation for precise ensemble phrasing. This voluminous interpretation of the Schubert "Great" was truly massive in its heavenly length, and yet genteel in execution - just the sort of portrait of the composer we know today.


 

Now CHIA HAN-LEON can't get rid of the walking theme from the 2nd movement of the Schubert out of his head.

If you wish to Add a Comment to this review, please post your comments to classical@inkpot.com.

Last Concert Reviewed | Next Concert Reviewed

Return to Index Return to the Classical Index!...
or Visit the Inkvault archives!
892: 20.6.2001 © Chia Han-Leon

All original texts are copyrighted. Please seek permission from the Classical Editor
if you wish to reproduce/quote Inkpot material.