Return to Classical Contents Page Find Old Articles Contact Writers Go to Inkpot.com

This article was last updated on
7 November, 2002

More Stuff:


ReSSOnance III It's the Unofficial ReSSOnance Forum.

Singapore Symphony Orchestra Homepage Season Programme available here.

SISTIC Where you buy tickets for SSO concerts.


Do you have a website relating to classical music performance in Singapore? Tell us about it! Email classical@inkpot.com


15 October 2002, Tuesday
Esplanade - Theatres on the Bay

Esplanade Opening Festival -
London Philharmonic Orchestra

Programme:

Ludwig van BEETHOVEN
Symphony No. 1 in C major, Op. 21

Anton BRUCKNER
Symphony No. 7 in E major

Performers: London Philharmonic Orchestra
conducted by Kurt Masur
NOISE RATING INDEX: 2 (Quiet audience, for its size, but still some people fidgeting. Otherwise, acoustics were really something else.)
The Noise Rating Index is a partially-objective measurement of pager and handphone blasts, 9pm and 10pm watch beeps, coughing-during-the-pianissimo-bits, intra-audience conversation and other mind-bogglingly inept noises emitted in the concert hall during actual performance of music. It is measured on a scale of 0 to 5, in increasing annoyance.
 
   
by William Beh
 

Along with the New York Philharmonic Orchestra, Zhang Yimou's Raise the Red Lantern and Forbidden City: Portrait of an Empress, the London Philharmonic Orchestra must surely be one of the hottest events at Esplanade's Opening Festival. Tickets, we hear, were all gone within days of going on public sale. And why not ? As one of the earliest groups to perform in the Festival, they could be expected to really give the state-of-the-art Concert Hall a real workout.

The Singapore Symphony's pre-opening Trial and Orientation performance on August 7th didn't really do anything than to demonstrate how unready they were for the new venue - although guest conductor Tateo Nakajima did lead the orchestra that evening in a smashing rendition of Smetana's Die Moldau (among a rojak of other items that included Schubert 5 and excerpts from Beethoven 9). The official inauguration of the hall on October 11th was even more of a curate's egg: a by-invitation-only junket for the rich and well-connected (despite the trumpeting avowal that "Esplanade - Theatres on the Bay is a performing arts centre for everyone.") Even the best of intentions needs a bit of compromise sometimes, I guess.

Bruckner in Singapore

On page 34 of the glossy "Opening Esplanade" commemorative book, there's a comment that "this would be the first time in Singapore that we get to hear a live performance of Bruckner Symphony No.7." This is actually incorrect. The Seventh was performed last in November 1993, in a programme that also included Liszt's First Piano Concerto (Jean-Philippe Collard soloing) and Greig's In Autumn Overture, conducted by Choo Hoey.

However, we do agree that Bruckner has been unjustly neglected - only four of his symphonies have been performed in the entire history of the SSO:

  • Symphony No.3 - 27/28 Feb 87
  • Symphony No.4 - 12/13 Sep 86, 9/10 Jun 89, 29/30 Nov 96
  • Symphony No.7 - 19/20 Nov 93
  • Symphony No.9 - 13/14 Aug 99

This, thankfully, will change quickly. We hear that the SSO is going to do two Bruckners in its 2003 season: the Eighth, under Okko Kamu in September, and the Seventh in October, which is also going with the orchestra on tour to China. There's also rumours of Mahler's 8th in the works for 2004. No, really.

But it was everyone, it seemed, who turned up for the London Phil. The night's audience, despite the absence of stipulated dress code, was a well-lacquered lifestyle bunch - ties and gowns were de rigeur, it seemed, in the unspoken, self-imposed fetish for dressing up that an infrequent bourgeois concertgoer might feel appropriate to the occasion. Certainly, the Esplanade is out to make a difference, from the way the ushers in smartly tailored uniforms greet you at every step of the way, to the humungous plasma screens hanging in the lobbies, to its no-nonsense policy on latecomers (no admission until suitable breaks) and cutoff age (six years old).

That said, there were still enough kids young enough to be not yet born when Bruckner's Seventh was last performed here, which gave me cause to fear the worst. How many of the audience were here simply because of the LPO "name" (and couldn't get tickets for last night), and how many were here genuinely for the rare opportunity to hear Bruckner ? How would they survive 60+ minutes of non-stop Teutonic Romanticism ? Apparently, the audience from the previous night had applauded their way through all the movements of the Prokofiev and Tchaikovsky!

But the concert started off with Beethoven's nascent First Symphony. Kurt Masur, last here in 1998 with the New York Philharmonic, adopted a fairly middle-of-the-road reading (maybe a bit on the leisurely side) with his trademark moderate tempi. What was remarkable (even though I'd fully expected nothing less) was his immaculate attention to detail on all fronts - the broad arcs of phrasing and the individual highlights on individual notes, as well as the the dynamics, the nuances of emphasis on different sections and the clean, transparent timbre of the classical-sized ensemble.

Insofar as the hall acoustics was concerned, it had a warm (four-second) resonance not unlike, say, The Snape, Maltings. The woodwind passages in the second movement, for example, acquired a glowing nimbus, as did the smallish string section. There was a clever rubato at the beginning of the last movement, before Masur propelled the music forward with animation and character. All in a superlative day's work for the good maestro, I suppose.

Needless to say, the big kahuna of the evening was Bruckner's 65-minute leviathan, coming after the break. With a greatly enchanced orchestra, including the famous quartet of Wagner tubas (on top of five horns), it promised to be something quite special - and it was. From the shimmering, scarcely audible string tremolando of the opening, it was clear that communion between conductor and orchestra, as well as among the sections of the orchestra, bordered on the telepathic.

The Philharmonic at the Movies

by Benjamin Chee

Like so many of the London orchestras, the London Philharmonic has seen its share of sessions work for the silver screen. It's probably fair to say that the lion's share of these movie projects have gone to the London Symphony, which recently just received a Platinum disc for 1,000,000 sales of the Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace soundtrack in the US. Other big movies under the LSO's belt include Raiders of the Lost Ark, Superman the Movie, Braveheart and Clash of the Titans. In fact, you can follow this list all the way back to 1936, when it recorded its first soundtrack for William Menzies's Things to Come.

Not to be outdone, the Philharmonic Orchestra has Entrapment, The King and I (the 1999 animated version) and Don Quixote to its discography. Another long-standing band, the Royal Philharmonic, harks all the way back to the original The Red Shoes of 1948, in addition to its contemporary participation in A Passage to India and Gangs of New York. The Academy of St Martin-in-the-Fields achieved worldwide renown for its collaboration on Amadeus, but it would be hard to think of another film project in which it featured prominently.

The LPO itself has done some good things: Ed Wood, The Cell and Existenz - all films with a touch of the eclectic, coincidentally or otherwise. But it has also distinguished itself with Lawrence of Arabia, and more recently, a 2002 Best Soundtrack Oscar effort on The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring. (Although the best portion of the soundtrack, the 20-minute sequence in the Mines of Moria, was performed by the New Zealand Symphony and a Maori-Samoan male choir.)

The sensitivity and response of the musicians to Masur's magical invocations was nothing short of rapturous, in the way the maestro constructed the arch of Bruckner's radiant theme over the near-silence, and then colouring it in with the mellow splendour of horns, woodwinds and low strings. It was a masterclass in how a world-class orchestra should play together.

Therein followed an exposition that was purposeful and yet lyrical, an undescribably beautiful but abstract creation of pure tonal beauty. Some of the full-house audience started fidgeting as early as ten minutes into the work, true, but these were in a small minority. For the most part, the audience was held in thrall through the musical tapestry of emotions, ebbing and flowing, punctuated with much gravitas by the brasses. No wonder this work was Bruckner's greatest success in his lifetime, as well as one which brought him "the fullest measure of joy."

Without rushing the tempo, Masur moulded the sublime Adagio in broad, expansive strokes, the players again responding as one. The strings were simply breathtaking, building up to the opulent, cathedral-like climax of the movement, with the grand, grand fortissimo enveloping every soul in the hall in its unapologetic bombast of absolute sound: liftoff. And then, the apocalyptic drop in dynamics from fff to ppp, with individual instruments voicing over barely-whispering strings. It was an intense, awe-inducing moment, a Brucknerian hallmark, brought to larger-than-life by Masur and Co.

The following Scherzo was fired with raw menace more than anything else, driven relentlessly by low strings and brasses. This was all the more accentuated by a gentle, illuminative Trio section, and I'll say this: in the spacious acoustic of the hall, the three-bar silence separating the Scherzo and Trio was just perfect. Leaving no note unturned and no phrase unexplored, Masur brought the journey to its noble apotheosis in a surefooted display of passion and poetry. This was glorious music accorded a sovereign performance, concluding in a veritable orgasm of sound that showed Singapore audiences what we really mean when we say world-class acoustics. The bar has been raised.

At the end of it all, I think it was the sheer capacity of Masur and the orchestra's ability to communicate so powerfully, that even the most dilettante audience member could not leave but unmoved, untransformed, untouched by what he or she had just experienced. This is the epitome of what great art is all about - the power of communication, of feeling and empathy, of shared experience, and not just for the well-heeled, either. An extraordinary concert for an extraordinary occasion.

William Beh is looking forward to The Two Towers (the movie, not KLCC).

If you wish to Add a Comment to this review, please post your comments to classical@inkpot.com.

Last Concert Reviewed | Next Concert Reviewed

Return to Index Return to the Classical Index!...
or Visit the Inkvault archives!

22.10.2002 © William Beh

All original texts are copyrighted. Please seek permission from the Classical Editor
if you wish to reproduce/quote Inkpot material.