Side Bar

RATING: *****

Flicker
Inside
This One's Mine
Treat Me Like Dirt
Looking For A Girl
Forgive Me
Up Against The Wall
Perfect Stranger
Out Of My Mind
Change Your Ways
Remembering Tonight
It's Alright

PATTI ROTHBERG
Between the 1 and the 9 (1996)
Capitol Records
[41:52]

by Kelvin Lee

What a pretty face on the front cover, not unlike Sheryl Crow, perhaps, whose first album was in a typically easy Californian style. The rear cover features a montage of Patti's self-portraits, drawn in her own hand during her teenage years -- a time when, like most of us, she too searched for an identity. Plain ol' Patti, Patti a la Warhol, married Patti, hippie Patti, and Patti the punk (the song titles are somewhere in between the portraits)... The paintings suggest another TFS (tortured female singer), more akin to Alanis Morisette than a feel- good Sheryl Crow. All over the artwork is a generalised feeling of clutter, tormented self-expression and frustration - perhaps just another day in a big grubby city?

A first spin of the CD yielded me no personal favourites - nothing particularly tuneful, just a clutter of very bluesy numbers which sounded like a female banshee in the bowels of a cold urban city. A general feeling of frustration, angst and urbanized clutter pervaded the whole album.

Her laments echo like the fleeting thoughts of our own experiences, screaming in our head when our bodies can only move ... to an urban crawl ... By the third listen some of the tunes started growing on me. This is a great album for identifying the things we do in a big crowded city - driving through traffic, getting trapped and paralyzed on the train, being stuck in a bus queue, and perhaps huddling with the morning crowd lining up for breakfast. Patti wails about broken love, loneliness, betrayal and hollow experiences, albeit mostly at a frenzied pace. Her laments echo like the fleeting thoughts of our own experiences screaming in our head when our bodies can only move in unison to an urban crawl, and any individualized action is impossible.

... tracks 12 to 18 are completely blank. On first starting the CD you might think it's a full 19 tracks in 43 minutes. In reality however, tracks 12 to 18 are completely blank. Track 19 is the title track and is not listed in the sleeve notes or the enclosed lyric sheet. But finding it is like striking gold - it's my personal favourite. Otherwise, the album moves in a generally urbanized blues direction, cranking into distortion around track 7 ("Up Against The Wall") and then toning down again on the more feeling numbers like track 12, "It's Alright."

Her vocals are sweet, bordering on raspy, and stylistically she sounds almost like Janis Joplin on "Forgive Me." With the musical emphasis on strong rhythms throughout the album, Patti shines in her handling of folk and twelve string guitars. Her riffing on lead guitar is pretty average, and whilst reminiscent of Joan Jett, falls short. Her vocals are sweet, bordering on raspy, and stylistically she sounds almost like Janis Joplin on "Forgive Me." Her voice, however, can be a little too sweet for rockish Joan Jett-styled numbers like the humbucker-driven, chorus-pedalled, powerchorded "Up Against The Wall." She sounds like Alanis Morisette with an added twist of frustration on tracks like "Flicker," and on "This One's Mine" there's an alternative touch, rather like Blind Melon.

.. simple, honest, and unpretentious ...
The tracks on this album were mostly written during her college days, and deal with issues like a girl's hopes, and boys. No Dylanesque inspirations here. Her match of lyrics to tunes are good (if not catchy) but can hardly be considered poetic in nature. In certain instances, they border on plain corny, as in "Flicker" where she writes: "Nightfall used to be your ocean and I your bridge across/ I survived your deadly potion and only you can feel the loss." However, I must add that at least they are simple, honest and unpretentious.

I'd recommend this album for the adventurous listener who appreciates urban blues. Don't judge this album till you've spinned it at least three to four times though.


KELVIN LEE is currently seeking to finance a television series called SINGAPOREAN GOTHIC, in which he stars as a diabolic Super-GRC mayor with absolute control over the housing conditions of his constituents... oooooohhhh.

more Music? Visit the Inkvault archives!

Other reviews by any writer can be obtained from the InkVault.

1997 ŠThe Flying Inkpot